Monday 21 July 2014

Anne Frank...

“People can tell you to keep your mouth shut, but that doesn't stop you from having your own opinion.”

I'm unable to not comment any longer. It makes me feel bad, like some sort of collaborator or one of those informers that sent Jewish people to the concentration camps in the war. But comment I must ,despite what anyone might think.

I read Anne Frank’s diary at school; well, everybody did. It was expected as part of some sort of post-holocaust rite of passage, even though the war had been over for twenty years. It made me very sad. Years later I made the pilgrimage to Amsterdam and her house to soak up her pain. That made me even sadder. 

Since then I’ve watched the films about boys in striped pyjamas and fiddlers on the roof, read the books - ‘is it safe?’, and listened to the survivors of the holocaust recounting their tales. I’ve even seen my Uncle Len’s photographs of Belsen – real pictures taken by him – snapped as he helped liberate that terrible place from the Nazis.

Awful. Dirty. Despicable. Too much to bear. It left the whole world guilt-ridden and attempting to make amends.

And then this. 

How did the people that suffered so much become the people inflicting suffering? Taking away another people’s pride, killing innocent children, stealing their land, sneering as they do it. 

It sounds too familiar. How is it justifiable?

No matter what the past, how can this be justified?

Two wrongs can never make a right. War is still war, murder still murder, and greed still greed.

I wonder what Anne Frank would make of it? I think that she would have lowered her pretty, dead, head and wept.

14 comments:

  1. Stephen Mcaleer on FB
    I agree with you Andy. Ordinary people are the victims. Both sides are led my people of extremist religious convictions. That gives then a licence to do anything. Both sides are using ancient texts to justify what they are doing.

    Stephen Mcaleer
    If anyone is going to be asked to keep their mouth shut, it won't be you Andy. I don't think anyone disagrees with you, I just think the leaders on both sides of the fence are fascists and civilians are the fuel for their fire.

    Stephen Mcaleer
    Israel has risen to the bait. The Islamists want this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Andrew Height
      It's a quote from Anne Frank Steve. Yes, the trap has been set and now we will watch the world take sides once again. What a mess.

      Delete
  2. Richard Shore on FB
    You don't count the dead, when god's on your side

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kevin Burke on FB
    Andy. Superbly put.. if I may I shall share your sentiments.. I am on a march in Rochdale on Sunday morning.. 100% agree with every word you said..

    ReplyDelete
  4. Tim Preston on FB
    I think that hatred and the ego are one. The ego is what you feel when you believe yourself to be right. It's one particular feeling. At one end you've got someone upset because they desperately need a pen to write something down and they can't find one and at the other end of the scale you've got genocide. The degree of emotion is different but the emotion is the same. I think that in every case you've got to drop the feeling ...... let it go. enjoy the freedom and consider your enemy as a fearful human being, the same as yourself. That is compassion and from it will come peace.

    Andrew Height
    You are right Tim. I give up. I''ll write it all Phnom the blog, but I despair at a people that have lived holocaust and learned noting. My worry is that we are all the same and will happily murder children because we are allowed to.

    Tim Preston
    give up?

    Tim Preston
    everyone needs happiness and you provide it - ffs don't give up!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Clare Pritchard on FB
    Agreed matey, took the words out of my mouth x Lest people forget....

    Clare Pritchard
    they asked people not to forget genocide.....and it seems what they are doing too, do not unto others....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Andrew Height
      I know it isn't that simple, but they are becoming invaders. Eventually you have to accept the past and move on. I'm sick of it and let's face it we only have the bible and the sovereign British government of the time to blame. I find it hard to work out who is the downtrodden here. But if I take a purely rational view then I don't. Is that wrong? Does that make me a fascist?

      Delete
    2. Clare Pritchard
      My nan always said to me, no biased on this one, they were years and years back classed as the wondering Jew, and had no homeland as such, i hate war and what it does to everybody, death, hatred, i try and spread my love locally, there is good and bad in every religion/race/belief etc....

      Delete
  6. Kevin Burkeon FB
    Couldn't agree more Andy.. Israel the biggest terrorists on the planet.. Disgustingly backed by the uk and usa..

    ReplyDelete
  7. Stephen Mcaleer on FB
    Given the media coverage it's easy to see fault wit Israel but don't forget the role HanMas plays in all this. Do you know the kind of world Hamas want you to live in?

    Stephen Mcaleer
    Hamas want this conflict

    Andrew Height
    A good reason not to give them what they want then.

    Stphen Mcaleer
    Yes, that's right. Hamas care absolutely nothing for the Palistinian people. But the more blood that is spilt, the more political capital Hamas receives. Look at the ideology behind Hamas. They are happy to see people killed if it helps them. Hamas would be very pissed off if there was peace tomorrow. The Palistinian people have always been led by mutters. That's why the whole thing drags on for years.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Andrew Height
    I watch the eyes of the Israeli generals on television as they defend the bombing of children and, despite their words, I hope that I see fear in the eyes of these liars. Tonight on The News at Ten they had no answers, only nervous sweat and empty phrases. They will be telling us that they were only following orders next. The world, who have supported these victims for so long, must act to stop others becoming their victims.

    Ian Maclachlan, David Searle, Annette Jones and 6 others like this.

    Kathryn Salthouse
    Totally agree

    Sarah Rawden
    I despair at how much hatred and anger there is in the world :o( xXx

    David Searle
    Shame on them.

    Andrew Height
    Shame on us all David Searle.

    David Searle
    To an extent. But it's always someone else who is responsible - the terrorists, the parents, the children, the western backers, etc.

    No - it is the Israeli politicians, generals and soldiers killing the children in an over populated blockaded prison camp.

    Paul Plant
    Andrew the world is becoming a scarier place chiefly because of weak toothless leadership by those who have the mandate to collectively act. I am not anti-Israel, but they have been allowed to flaunt UN resolutions for more than forty years. They consider themselves above international law. The UN expresses "horror" that its people have been blown up today, yet I'll lay a strong wager that absolutely ZERO action will be taken.

    Andrew Height
    Action needs to be taken though. You are right Paul Plant, I'm not anti-Israel either but I find it hard to reconcile the taught pity for the Jewish people of my schooldays with what the Israelis are doing and have been doing for so long. That card, I'm afraid, begins to feel overplayed.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Linda Kemp on FB
    how is it that an Israeli life is priceless yet all those Palestinian lives seem to be worthless?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Barry Jones on FB
    Why are UN resolutions not enforced? Israel shouldn't be in the West Bank, East Jerusalem or the Gaza Strip,

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Andrew Height
      Good question Mr Barry Jones

      Delete