So the new John Lewis is here. I know, I know, it’s cute, it
tugs at the heartstrings, that little boy is adorable, and everyone loves a
penguin.
Yes it is all so cute, so adorable, so lovely, and all so completely
bloody cynical.
The ad is basically a sales tool for Monty the penguin
merchandise. Nothing wrong with that you might say, ads are meant to sell
product, and you would be right. What I think is very wrong is making a not
very well-made stuffed penguin into a ‘must have’ gift and then selling it for
£95, a staggering £185 if you want Monty’s practically identical girlfriend
Mabel (both typically John Lewis names) so that the two of them can remain a
couple.
Let’s not be fooled, this ad isn’t about love, or sentiment,
or nice deeds at Christmas. It’s about grabbing as much money as possible for
as little as possible. If you look carefully at the ad you’ll see all the John
Lewis penguin products you could wish for. You are being manipulated,
brainwashed to need these things.
Are people really this gullible? Apparently yes they are.
John Lewis sold out of Monty toys within hours of the advert launch. Just who
is so naïve to allow John Lewis to tug at their overly sentimental heartstrings
in order to sell them such tat? Who would pay almost 100 quid for a toy that
you could pick up for less than a fiver in any discount toy store?
Many people are saying that this ad is the best ad yet.
Well, I guess it depends on your perspective, your definition of best, and if
you don’t mind being taken for a bloody fool by a major store who should know
better.
I can imagine grandmothers all over the county tutting as
they blow a couple of weeks pension on these cuddly toys, but doing it anyway
as little Ben, Grace, Charlie and Fleur will simply adore their very own Monty
and his sweetheart. Yes, the little darlings really must have one, so the old
dears will part with their money and then wander home to a cold flat that they
can’t afford to heat.
But it doesn’t end with cuddly cloth penguins. The soft toy
is only part of the Monty range. John Lewis has produced 39 pieces of Monty
merchandise including umbrellas, onesies and cufflinks, which also sold out
within hours along with those shabby Monty toys.
It seems the world is Monty mad. Well, mad anyway.
As for Sam, the rather strange seven year old boy in the ad,
it seems to me that the poor boy needs help. It’s fine to believe that his
penguin is real - an active imagination is a good thing - but his concern with
his toy penguin’s love life is, well to be frank, a little unsettling. Not only
is that penguin in need of a bloody good wash, but is it really normal for a
seven year old to fixate on a penguin’s sexual needs?
This is boy who may grow up to seek love with a little too
much passion, a boy that might become addicted to romance, or a stalker, a
serial philanderer, a sex addict, maybe even something worse. He’s well on the
way to becoming a voyeur as he watches the penguins make whoopee with that
strangely over-interested smile on his face - and all because his parents
spoilt him by buying him an overpriced stuffed rag penguin one Christmas.
Yes, there’s a moral in this: don’t pay £95 for a cheap
cuddly toy, make an ass of yourself, and send John Lewis laughing all the way
to the bank. If you do your child may grow up to be one of those weird people
who hang around farmyards watching the chickens mate.
Jayne Butterworth on FB
ReplyDeletePaul agrees but i think its quite normal u mean pingu isnt real? Ha ha! Actually made me laugh! We prefer last yr. Gud marketing for penguin sales at john lewis!
Andrew Height
DeleteThe Devil's work Jayne.
Sharon Taylor on FB
ReplyDeleteJohn Lewis are charging £95 for a very mediocore soft toy, not very in keeping with the Christmas spirit!
Andrew Height
DeleteWhich is why I am no fan of John Lewis Sharon.
Sharon Taylor
DeleteI must admit to being very unimpressed
.
Andrew Height
DeleteI call it cynical manipulation.
Sharon Taylor
DeleteAKA Capitalism.........
Andrew Height
Deleteat the very least.
Fraser Stewart on FB
ReplyDeleteI still hate Christmas
Andy B D Bickerdike on FB
ReplyDeleteI couldn't agree more.
Laura Keegan on FB
ReplyDeleteAnd there I was feeling all warm & festive! Love your cynical viewpoint.
Andrew Height I
Deletet's not me Laura, it's John Lewis. Without the merchandising the ad would just be cute and weird. As it stands it's just an exercise in ripping people off. I don't mind (well I do, but so what?), I won't buy them, but it does need pointing out because it isn't all right
Laura Keegan
DeleteI meant that, I do love it. Not sarcastic at all. Your interpretation gives a different viewpoint, I wouldn't have seen any of that. Very interesting. Although I did not feel compelled to go out and buy them, I am shocked at the price of Monty & Mabel
Sharon Taylor on FB
ReplyDeleteI have just watched it, I would have been a bit less disappointed if it had been a homeless person, rather than a happy couple and that about £70 per toy went the Shelter. My friend spent all last night out in the cold with no friend for support to raise money for the homeless. I will be donating to her charity and not to John Lewis.
Andy B D Bickerdike on FB
ReplyDeleteGoing to read before sleep
Lindsey Messenger on FB
ReplyDeleteand its not even Christmassy!!!